If you are a Chicago homeowner planning your estate, you have surely heard that a trust can make it easier to transfer your assets (including your home) to your loved ones. Trusts avoid probate, keep your affairs private, and safeguard assets from creditors. One survey indicated that just around one-third of Americans have an estate plan in place, even though 56% believe preparation is vital. That gap demonstrates why a proper estate planning guide is so important.
One useful but sometimes misleading tool is the 5 and 5 power (also referred to as a 5 by 5 power). In simple terms, this is an option you can include in a trust that allows the beneficiary to take out a set amount each year. Exactly, the beneficiary may withdraw the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the fair market value of the trust annually. Note that these withdrawals are not mandatory, but are instead optional. That is, the beneficiary can draw out that money, but doesn’t have to.
Let’s analyze how it works, why folks utilize (and sometimes do not) it, and what Chicago homeowners need to know when establishing such a trust.
Why Trusts Matter in Estate Planning
Trusts often beat simple wills for many homeowners. A living trust (irrevocable or revocable) allows you to control exactly who receives what and when. Unlike a will, a trust does not go through probate and can shield heirs from creditors or even lawsuits. You may also put conditions on payments from the trust – for instance, only paying out when an individual reaches a certain age or requires money for college. Due to these advantages, trusts are an integral part of any good Illinois estate planning resource.
According to Illinois trust law, you may put nearly any valid clause in the trust document. A 5-and-5 power is just one of them. If your trust provides a beneficiary with this power, Illinois courts will enforce it just as with any other rule for distribution. Essentially, Illinois trusts work much the same way they do everywhere else; the secret is having the trust properly drawn by an experienced estate planning attorney.
What is 5 and 5 Power in Estate Planning?
5 and 5 power of attorney is a discretionary clause in certain trusts that governs yearly withdrawals. It allows the beneficiary to withdraw each year whichever is greater: $5,000 or 5% of the value of the trust. For example:
- Trust value $10,000. Five percent is $500, so the beneficiary could still withdraw $5,000 (the greater amount) in that year. That would actually be 50% of the trust’s total, so be careful – a small trust like this could be exhausted quickly.
- Trust value $50,000. Five percent is $2,500, but the beneficiary can take $5,000 (the larger of $5k or 5%).
- Trust value $200,000. Five percent is $10,000. Since that’s bigger than $5,000, the beneficiary could take up to $10,000 that year.
These illustrations demonstrate how the rule applies. You can observe that for trusts below $100,000, the $5,000 amount typically takes center stage; for bigger trusts, the 5% rule governs the split. (If a trust is precisely $100,000, 5% is $5,000, so the maximum is $5,000 that year.)
Most importantly, the beneficiary is not obligated to exercise this authority. They can simply refuse to take anything out, keeping the money invested in the trust. That way, the trust assets can just keep growing if the beneficiary does not require cash.
How Does the 5 and 5 Power Work?
Under the hood, the 5-and-5 power is mainly about cash flow and taxes. It allows the beneficiary to have access to some money every year without giving them the entire estate outright. Technically, it’s intended to be in line with federal tax regulations (IRC §2041(b)(2)), but the outcome benefits the family. Tax-wise, every year the beneficiary elects to receive from the trust, that amount is considered income of the beneficiary (so they pay tax on it), instead of keeping it all within the trust. This tends to lower the taxes on the trust assets overall. The 5-and-5 provision was utilized to “reduce capital gains taxation on the assets in a trust or distribute a big chunk of money in bits and pieces”.
In practical terms for families: if your Chicago trust has investments that generate dividends or interest, allowing a beneficiary to take out $5,000 (or 5%) per year can transfer the tax to the beneficiary’s bracket and save tax for the trust/estate.
You can also tailor a 5-and-5 clause for your circumstances. For instance, the trust document can state that the beneficiary can use the yearly withdrawal only for some purposes – such as payment of tuition fees, buying a first home, medical bills, or funding a business venture. This adds another level of security to the 5-and-5 rule: it’s not just “you get up to $X per year,” but “you get that much for education or emergencies.” By contrast, if there’s no condition, the beneficiary could use the money however they like.
In summary, the 5-and-5 power works by: (1) setting a clear yearly withdrawal limit ($5k or 5%); (2) making withdrawals optional each year; and (3) shifting tax liability to the beneficiary on the withdrawn amount. It’s a built-in flexibility in the trust.
Why Include a 5 and 5 Power Clause?
In the right scenario, the 5-and-5 power can be a great benefit to beneficiaries. Here are some reasons you might choose to add it:
- Guaranteed Annual Income. It provides the recipient with a guaranteed ability to withdraw funds annually. This can function as an income floor. If one wants a predictable sum of cash (perhaps for living costs or small investments), they know they can withdraw the 5-and-5. For example, a retiring spouse or in-school adult child may depend on that annual withdrawal.
- Flexibility and Choice. The beneficiary is not required to take it. They can forego withdrawals in years when they do not require cash, allowing the money to accumulate. Such a voluntary aspect (highlighted by estate planning specialists) provides the beneficiary with freedom without jeopardizing the structure of the trust.
- Tax Efficiency. As mentioned, money withdrawn is taxed to the beneficiary, and not to the trust. This helps maintain the tax benefits of the trust. A good tactic employed to lower estate taxes, since it keeps withdrawals from the taxable income of the beneficiary.
- Controlled Payouts. Capping the withdrawal at $5k or 5% ensures the trustor is aware that the assets will not be used up too rapidly. It’s a middle ground between having access and not being able to make one big withdrawal. For instance, instead of writing a check for $100,000 all at once, the beneficiary has to take it in pieces.
- Customization. You can link the 5-and-5 clause to certain uses (education, home buying, etc.), essentially making it a mini “budget” clause. Others make it so that withdrawals need to be approved for some goals, which the trustee can track.
- No Mandatory Draw-Down. Unlike an annuity, there is no obligation to exercise the right. If the beneficiary is self-disciplined or the investments within the trust are paying more than 5%, the capital may continue to build.
Potential Drawbacks and Considerations
The 5-and-5 power isn’t perfect for every situation. Here are some things to watch out for:
- Risk of Running Out of Funds. If the value of the trust is fairly modest, withdrawals of $5,000 a year can exhaust it rapidly. One case in point: a $20,000 trust can be drained of its funds in 4 years if the beneficiary withdraws $5,000 a year. Likewise, a $60,000 trust would last only around 12 years at $5k/year. So if you want the trust to last for decades, a low limit like this may not work.
- Rigid Limit. The rule is fixed. If a beneficiary suddenly needs more (for example, an unexpected $20,000 medical bill), they can’t withdraw beyond the $5k/5% limit. The trust would need a separate provision or emergency fund for that. As Trust & Will notes, this rigidity can be a downside if circumstances change and the beneficiary needs more than the preset amount.
- “Use It or Lose It.” Unused withdrawal privileges do not roll over to the following year. That is, if the beneficiary doesn’t use $5,000 in a year, they don’t receive $10,000 the following year – it’s lost. This causes beneficiaries to need to plan when (or whether) to withdraw their 5-and-5 allowance annually.
- Loss of Trust Protection. As soon as funds are pulled out through the 5-and-5 authority, they become the asset of the beneficiary. At that stage, any creditor, lawsuit, or divorce claim against them can access those funds. Conversely, funds remaining in the trust may be protected by such items as spendthrift clauses. Thus, there is a trade-off between providing beneficiaries with cash and assets remaining protected.
- Inflation and Dollar Limits. The $5,000 amount might depreciate over time because of inflation. If the trust holds for decades, $5k in 2025 might not travel very far during 2045. One might review the trust later on, but when it’s irrevocable, that’s not straightforward.
- Not One-Size-Fits-All. If you have extremely specific objectives (e.g., paying for graduate school or a first house), it may be preferable to employ a different clause. Discretionary distributions by the trustee or age-based distributions (pay $X at 25, $Y at 30) may be more appropriate. The 5-and-5 is somewhat “one-dimensional” – it merely quantifies value and pays out a percentage.
Although the 5 and 5 power allows flexibility, it’s not required in a trust and can restrict how quickly money flows out. Consider how big your trust is, your beneficiaries’ needs, and whether $5,000 or 5% annually meets your objectives. As one attorney’s example noted, if the trust is only $50,000, $5,000 per year would only last a decade – not very long for a retirement fund or college savings plan.
5 and 5 Power under Illinois Trust Law
If you’re living in Illinois or the Chicago area, don’t worry: the 5-and-5 rule is entirely legal in this state. Illinois trust law (following the Uniform Trust Code) normally requires whatever rules you set for distribution in the trust to be followed. There is no law requiring 5-and-5 or prohibiting it. This clause is commonly used in many Illinois estate planning lawyers’ documents routinely, when it is appropriate.
A 5 by 5 power of withdrawal clause in a trust entitles the beneficiary to withdraw 5 percent or $5,000 – whichever is larger – of the trust’s fair market value annually. That description applies just as well in Cook County as anywhere else. Illinois trusts often use spendthrift clauses to protect assets from creditors. (Keep in mind, though, that once the beneficiary takes cash under 5-and-5, that cash is no longer in the spendthrift-protected trust, so they hold it outright.)
Illinois lawyers can also include provisions that suspend payments until a specific age or penalize someone with a no-contest clause if they sue the trust. You could combine these with 5-and-5 as necessary. For example, you could provide that a young heir does not receive lump sums until age 30, but may otherwise exercise the 5-and-5 power each year for living expenses or education expenses. The point is that Illinois trusts are very flexible; the 5-and-5 power is merely one of many tools available.
One additional Illinois-specific point: If your trust contains property (such as your house in Chicago), keep in mind that the 5-and-5 calculation is made on the fair market value of the trust, which would include the house if it’s in the trust. You may get your trust appraised annually to calculate 5% of its worth. (Often, trusts will employ a rough estimate valuation or use financial statements in this regard.) The 5-and-5 power can thus allow a beneficiary to essentially draw on home equity over time without the property having to be turned over to the beneficiary.
How to Include a 5 and 5 Power in Your Trust
Adding a 5-and-5 clause is not something to guess at. Here are some basic steps (with a Chicago focus) for putting it in place:
- Define Your Estate Plan Objectives. Determine who you want in the trust (your spouse? your children? your grandchildren?), what properties enter (bank accounts, investments, property, including your Chicago residence), and what you desire. Determine whether a trust is suitable (most often a revocable living trust), and whether or not you would like a controlled yearly drawdown.
- Choose the Right Trust Type. Consult with an Illinois estate planning attorney to select a trust type. Revocable trusts can be modified while you live; irrevocable trusts usually cannot (except under special rules). The 5-and-5 authority may be placed in either, but if you desire flexibility to amend it later, a revocable trust facilitates the modification.
- Pick Your Trustee and Beneficiary. Decide who will serve as trustee (the person who handles the trust) and who receives distributions (the beneficiary). The beneficiary is usually a spouse or child. The person (or trust company in Illinois) who might be the trustee should be clearly explained to the beneficiary about their role and rights.
- Draft the 5-and-5 Clause With an Attorney. Work with your estate planning attorney to place the clause in the trust instrument. For instance, the language of the trust could read: “Every year the beneficiary will be entitled to withdraw from the principal of this trust the higher of $5,000 or 5% of the fair market value of the trust as valued every year.” Adjust wording accordingly (for Illinois trusts, the 5% typically is based on an FMV established at the beginning of the year). Also include any conditions (e.g., “for education, health, or emergency needs only” if wished). Ensure it’s clear – a badly drafted clause may cause controversy.
- Include Any Additional Protections. You can add other provisions on top by having your lawyer do so. For instance, you could include a spendthrift clause to protect trust assets before distribution, or ask the beneficiary to be of a certain age (e.g., 25) before exercising the 5-and-5 power (still allowing them to exercise it in the meantime for specific bills). This will be based on your family’s circumstances.
- Sign and Fund the Trust. Once written, sign the trust document (in the presence of a notary public, since Illinois requires this). Next, fund the trust: move bank accounts, investment accounts, and real estate into the name of the trust. For a residence, this involves recording a deed to the trust. Keep in mind that any asset you wish to be protected by the 5-and-5 power needs to be within the trust corpus.
- Review Regularly. It’s a good idea to check your trust every few years. The flat $5,000 may lose its effectiveness, or tax legislation changes. If your trust is revocable, you (or subsequently your successor trustee) can change it. If it’s irrevocable, you can discuss decanting (transferring assets to a new trust) with an attorney if modifications are required.
- Communicate with Beneficiaries. Ensure your selected beneficiary is aware of the 5-and-5 rule. They should be aware of what they can withdraw and how, and what this will mean for their taxes and expenditures. Straightforward communication may avoid surprises and disputes later.
Throughout this process, it’s crucial to work with an estate planning attorney licensed in Illinois. A qualified lawyer will ensure your 5 and 5 power in trust is written correctly.
Choosing the Best Estate Planning Attorney
Since trusts and the 5-and-5 power can get complicated, hiring a good lawyer is essential. Search for a Chicago or surrounding area estate planning attorney (law firm) that specializes in trusts and estates. Inquire about their experience in writing individualized trusts, particularly if they have included 5-and-5 clauses in the past. Check online reviews or credentials (some lawyers are Certified Specialists). The finest estate planning lawyers will share your objectives and outline in simple terms how a 5-and-5 power would apply to you.
A good lawyer will also notify you of options. For example, if you’re concerned that $5,000 is not sufficient annually, he or she may recommend other possibilities (such as a different percentage or an income trust). They can play with numbers on your holdings, estimate tax implications, and customize the estate plan. Their ultimate responsibility is to ensure the trust (with or without 5-and-5) into your comprehensive estate plan – including wills, beneficiary designations, and other components.
How to Add 5 and 5 Power to Your Trust
If you’ve decided a 5-and-5 clause might fit your estate plan, here’s a simplified step-by-step overview of how to put it in place:
- Discuss with an Attorney: Schedule a meeting with a qualified estate planning attorney in Illinois. Explain what you want the trust to do, and ask if a 5-and-5 clause makes sense. (The attorney can assess whether it aligns with your goals and trust size.)
- Identify Beneficiaries: Decide who will hold this withdrawal right (often a spouse or adult child). If multiple people are beneficiaries, clarify whether each person gets their own 5-and-5 power. For example, if two siblings inherit, the trust might allow each of them $5,000 or 5% separately each year.
- Draft the Trust Language: Work with your attorney to write the exact clause. A typical sentence might read: “Each year, the beneficiary may withdraw from the trust principal the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust’s fair market value on January 1 of that year.” Insert this into the trust document in the distribution or powers section. The attorney will ensure it’s properly formatted and integrated with other clauses.
- Set Conditions (Optional): If you want limits (e.g., only for education or health), have your attorney add those conditions around the clause. Specify how the funds may be used. For example, “such withdrawals shall be used for the beneficiary’s education, medical expenses, or housing needs.”
- Finalize the Trust: Sign the trust with all legal formalities (notary, witnesses if required). The trust document should list the 5-and-5 power exactly as agreed.
- Fund the Trust: Transfer assets into the trust’s name. This could be bank accounts, investments, or your Chicago property deed. Make sure the trust’s corpus includes all the assets to which the 5-and-5 rule will apply.
- Inform the Trustee and Beneficiary: Give a copy of the trust to the trustee (the person who will manage it) and to the beneficiary. Explain how and when the beneficiary can exercise the withdrawal each year.
- Review and Adjust: Keep your trust documents in a safe place. Check them every few years. If you ever need to change the 5-and-5 amount or rules, you’ll need to amend the trust (if revocable) or use special procedures (if irrevocable).
Following these steps with professional guidance will ensure the 5 and 5 power is set up correctly in your estate plan. It’s worth noting that many people refer to such checklists as part of their estate planning guide, so doing this right now saves problems later.
Getting Help With the 5 and 5 Power Rule and Other Estate Planning Tools
The 5 and 5 power is an effective planning tool, but it’s not suitable for everybody. If your trust is minimal or your beneficiary’s needs are straightforward, you might conclude it’s not necessary. Conversely, for bigger estates or beneficiaries who need to be supported in the long term, it can be extremely beneficial. Just be certain to keep it particular in the trust agreement and pay close attention to how it plays with tax regulations and trust policy.
In the end, the goal is to give your loved ones what they need while following your wishes. A well-drafted 5-and-5 clause can do exactly that – letting them access funds without handing them a big check all at once. And if you’re ever unsure, talking to one of the best estate planning attorneys will clarify how this clause fits into your Chicago-area estate plan. Good luck, and happy planning!
Frequently Asked Questions
It provides the beneficiary with a right annually to withdraw either $5,000 or 5% of the value of the trust (whichever is greater) from the trust. They get to decide whether to withdraw that amount or not. Essentially, it provides them with some access to cash every year if they need it. For instance, if the trust is valued at $200,000, 5% would be $10,000, so the beneficiary might withdraw up to $10,000 in that year. It is defined in estate planning terms as providing for annual withdrawals at that designated level.
No, not really. The 5-and-5 power is voluntary. The beneficiary has the ability to forego the withdrawal and keep the money in the trust if they wish. Such flexibility is intentional. As an example, Trust & Will explains that the clause does not compel withdrawals – it simply presents the choice. Foregoing one year does not grant additional rights down the line (it’s use it or lose it, as mentioned earlier).
Yes. Illinois law fully acknowledges trusts with a 5-and-5 clause. The provisions you put in your Illinois trust document (within legal boundaries) are typically enforced by Illinois courts. There’s no special Illinois limitation on it. Just see that the language is clear, and have an Illinois trust attorney assist with drafting.
When the money is withdrawn under the 5-and-5 rule, that amount is taxed as the beneficiary’s income, not trust income. It typically results in the trust itself receiving a deduction for the distribution (preventing double taxation). It further implies that the beneficiary will report the withdrawn money on their tax return. If the trust assets remained within, dividends or profits would be taxed to the trust (usually at higher rates). So one of the advantages of 5-and-5 is a tax reallocation to the beneficiary. (Comment: Excess funds remaining in the trust will continue to accrue within the trust and will be taxed under trust tax regulations.)
It depends. If your trust is revocable (you can modify it while living), you can modify or eliminate the clause at any time before your passing using your attorney. If the trust is irrevocable, it is much more difficult to modify; you would have to use legal mechanisms such as decanting or court amendment, which are complicated. This is the reason why most people begin with a revocable trust and only convert it to irrevocable (if at all) after they’re certain about everything. Always discuss with your lawyer how flexible the trust is.
Why Choose 23 Legal
23 Legal offers Real Estate and Estate Planning legal services to individuals, families, community associations and small business owners throughout Chicagoland. We know how intimidating “the law” can be. In fact, when most people think of law offices, they think of stuffy leather chairs, huge wooden desks and pompous lawyers who charge outrageous fees. That’s not us! We believe in 1-to-1; the same lawyer should work with you all the way through. Whether you have an estate planning issue, family trust concern, or you have a legal problem in regard to a new home, business, real estate or remodel, you need a lawyer who cares. That’s where Ben comes in! We are great listeners; more than that, we are lawyers who believe that our clients always come first.